Screen People: How We Entertained Ourselves into a State of Emergency
By Megan Garber
Page I bailed on: 60
Verdict: There was nothing much wrong with this, but it felt like a grab-bag of research into a field that has been worked intensively for the last twenty years or so, mixed in with some contemporary politics and pop culture references.
Actually the sorts of arguments being made go back more than twenty years, with the deans of this sort of analysis being names like George Orwell, Christopher Lasch, and Neil Postman, all of whom are referenced here. Even the subtitle, How We Entertained Ourselves into a State of Emergency is just a rewording of Postman’s Amusing Ourselves to Death. I did think Garber had some interesting ideas, like how the algorithms lead to our moral corruption, but they needed to be developed further in ways that let her speak more in her own voice. Instead, Screen People reads more like a student paper intent on mentioning, however briefly and incidentally, as many of its sources as possible. But outside of a student paper you don’t score any points for this and after a while it got tiring.