Panic Volume 1
As a long, long time fan of MAD Magazine – it’s fair to say I grew up with MAD – I was really keen on seeing this reprint of Panic, which was a sort of sister publication (less charitably, a knockoff) also put out by EC after they saw the success MAD was having and the numerous imitators that were coming out from other publishers. Given that MAD was the baby of Harvey Kurtzman while Panic was helmed by the seemingly inexhaustible Al Feldstein, and it was Feldstein who would go on to takeover MAD, you could even see this as the true proto-MAD, especially given the artists involved (particularly Jack Davis and Bill Elder) and the feature-movie parodies. Sure these latter would become more restrained (sticking closer to the actual source films) and wait to get Mort Drucker involved to become all-time classics, but you can sense where they were heading.
The issues collected here all came out in 1954, so Bob Fingerman has a bit of a point in his Foreword calling them out for being dated. What we have is “a funny history book, a window into the pop culture of yore, seen through a filter of bad puns, good jokes, and great art.” I can imagine a lot of people today scratching their heads at a send-up of radio serials or the ads that ran in the newspaper comics sections. Do young people even know what radio was? I’m pretty sure they’ll have never heard of movies like Hondo, Executive Suite, or How to Marry a Millionaire, and maybe not even The Quiet Man. One running gag (and they really went in for running gags, not just between stories but issues) has to do with Walt Kelly’s Pogo comic. But again, for all its cultural prominence and legacy, I have to wonder how many people today are even aware of Pogo. So, yes, this is a history book of sorts.
Things get off to a great start with a send-up of Mickey Spillane’s Mike Hammer novels called “My Gun Is the Jury!” As with any parody though, your enjoyment of it is going to rely on knowing what it is that’s being satirized. And right after this there’s a take-off of the TV show “This Is Your Life” that plays out as a murder mystery. Even if you don’t know anything about that show (and who does?) it still tells an interesting story.
From this peak, however, I thought there were more misses than hits in the writing. Even the main tag-line, “humor in a varicose vein,” doesn’t strike me as very funny. The attempts to render the Irish accents in “The Quite-a-Man!” are painful And the oft-repeated “fershlugginer” and “potrzebie” didn’t work either. I wasn’t even sure how to pronounce “potrzebie.”
So different times. So different that the first issue was even banned in Massachusetts after a parody of “’The Night Before Christmas” offended the usual bunch of scolds. And for what? This was a Bill Elder piece, which if you know his work involves crowding a lot of textual gags in nearly every frame. In one picture Santa’s sleigh has a sign on the back saying “Just Divorced!”, which I guess bothered Boston Catholics since Santa is technically a saint. The cultural controversies of yesteryear seem so quaint today.









