I really should have enjoyed this one, and the fact that I didn’t was a clear indication to me that the series is played out.
The reason I thought I should have liked it is that it has such a narrow focus. Maigret is woken from a dream (he has an active dream life) by a phone call from his friend Dr. Pardon, who has had to do some emergency surgery on a mysterious couple who then disappear as soon as he sews the patient up. It turns out she had been shot. The next day her husband is found to have been shot as well, only fatally.
So the question is Who killed Félix Nahour? The wife? The wife’s lover? The maid? The seedy secretary? It’s a neat little mystery involving conflicting passions and loyalties, with all of the suspects lying to Maigret about pretty much everything.
Unfortunately, it’s a neat little mystery without a neat little solution. This is another one of those Maigret stories where the detective chief inspector just gets a feel for what’s going on and nails it. But how are we supposed to play along? What clues were tipping Maigret off? Especially since the double shooting was such a bizarre event in the first place. I also didn’t understand the motivation of the killer. They should have resolved their personal issues with Nahour long before things came to the point they did.
4 thoughts on “Maigret: Maigret and the Nahour Case”
I don’t like being disappointed in a book or not getting how it was worked out. One of Wolfe’s does that and I get really annoyed.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m the same way. It’s a mystery and there are certain rules. You have to play fair with the reader.
LikeLiked by 2 people
What kind of case is it? It it made of real Nahour?
Faux Nahour. Pleather.